top of page

Let's Have an AA Meeting: Appearance vs. Authenticity

Writer: Claire Maendel
Claire Maendel
17 hours ago
6 min read

Welcome to Appearance Anonymous. The first step is admitting that sometimes we are more concerned with looking the part than actually living it.

Let's be honest. We all care about appearances to some degree. We want to be liked, respected, admired, and thought of favorably. There is nothing necessarily unusual about that. But what happens when the appearance of something becomes much more important than the substance of it?


What happens when we become so invested in how others perceive us that we lose sight of who we actually are? Perhaps it’s time we had a little meeting with ourselves.


The Image We Create


It is interesting how much effort people can put into managing the way others perceive them.


We can carefully choose what to share, what to hide, which parts of our lives to highlight, and which parts are better left unseen. We can become quite skilled at presenting a version of ourselves that is appealing to others. Unfortunately, something like social media allows people to do this with ease. 


But an image is not necessarily an accurate reflection of character.


Someone can speak about honesty without being truthful. They can talk about kindness without showing much compassion. They can present themselves as hardworking and responsible while quietly avoiding the very responsibilities they claim to value. Something that has helped me in the past is imagining my life (or someone else's life) as a silent movie. If I didn’t hear any of the words - what would the actions look like? In other words, am I holding my actions accountable to my words?


It’s perhaps one of the more difficult things to recognize. What we see on the outside does not always align with what is happening underneath.


We may become so focused on looking successful that we lose sight of what genuine success actually means. We may want the recognition that comes with being a good person without necessarily putting in the work that genuine character requires.


But appearances can only tell us so much.


The Difference Between Appearing and Being


There is a difference between talking about values and living by them.


It is one thing to say we value family, but another to make the effort to nurture those relationships. It is one thing to speak about integrity, but another to demonstrate it when doing so comes at a personal cost.


Character is not necessarily revealed in the things we say about ourselves. More often, it is revealed through the decisions we make, the responsibilities we accept, and the way we treat people when there is nothing to gain.


Perhaps the real test of character is not how we behave when others are watching, but how we behave when there is no audience.


Do our actions reflect our words? Are we willing to acknowledge when we are wrong? Can we take responsibility without immediately looking for someone else to blame?


These are not always comfortable questions to ask ourselves.


It is much easier to recognize these inconsistencies in other people than it is to examine them in our own lives. But authenticity requires a willingness to look inward, even when what we find is not particularly flattering.


The Cost of Maintaining Appearances


There can be a certain exhaustion that comes with trying to maintain an image.


When we become overly concerned with what others think, we can begin making decisions based on perception rather than conviction. We may avoid admitting mistakes because doing so threatens the image we have worked so hard to establish. We might defend our actions rather than consider whether we could have handled something differently. Sometimes, defensiveness can be worth examining. When we feel an unusually strong need to protect ourselves from questions or criticism, it may be worth asking whether there is something uncomfortable we are avoiding. 


Over time, protecting an image can become more important than pursuing personal growth.


And what does that leave us with?


Perhaps relationships that look good from the outside but lack honesty beneath the surface. Perhaps accomplishments that bring recognition but little personal fulfilment. Perhaps a life that appears to be everything we wanted, yet leaves us feeling disconnected from what actually matters.


The truth is that we cannot grow if we are unwilling to acknowledge where we fall short.


We cannot become better versions of ourselves while constantly convincing ourselves that we have nothing to work on.


There is a certain freedom in being able to admit that we don't have everything figured out. That we have made mistakes. That we have areas where we need to grow.


Authenticity does not require perfection. It requires honesty.


What Remains When Nobody is Watching?


I sometimes think we underestimate the significance of the ordinary, unseen moments in our lives.


The conversations nobody else hears. The decisions nobody knows about. The way we speak about someone when they are not present. The responsibilities we either take seriously or quietly push aside.


These moments may never become part of the story we tell others about ourselves, but they are still part of the story we are living.


And perhaps they reveal more about us than any carefully constructed image ever could.


We can influence how people perceive us to some extent, but we cannot always control what they believe. Nor should we spend our lives trying to do so. My Grandma used to say - “It’s okay if someone is talking about me behind my back, because at least they are leaving other people alone.” 


Some people will misunderstand us. Others will make assumptions based on limited information. And sometimes, no matter how carefully we explain ourselves, we will not be able to change someone's perception.

And that’s always the risk we take when we are authentic.

Perhaps the better question is whether we are comfortable with the person we are when the opinions of others are removed from the equation. And perhaps we sometimes place too much importance on the appearance of being surrounded by people, while overlooking the depth and authenticity of the relationships themselves. Having a large circle of friends, or being well liked by many, doesn't necessarily mean having meaningful connections. Sometimes, the most genuine relationships are found in much smaller circles.


Looking Beyond The Surface


There is a passage in 1 Samuel 16:7 that offers a meaningful reminder:


"People look at the outward appearance, but the Lord looks at the heart."


It is easy to become preoccupied with what can be seen. We notice appearances, achievements, possessions, and outward displays of success. But God sees beyond all of that.


He sees our intentions, our motivations, and the condition of our hearts.


And perhaps that is something worth remembering when we become too concerned with how we are perceived by others.


We don't need to spend our lives proving that we are good, successful, capable, or worthy. Instead, we can focus on the kind of people we are becoming.


Are we growing in patience? Are we becoming more honest? Are we willing to forgive, to take responsibility, and to recognize where we need to change?


These things may not always be visible to the world, but they matter. There is an interesting concept explored in the book The Courage to Be Disliked by Ichiro Kishimi and Fumitake Koga. One of its central ideas is that freedom involves accepting that not everyone will like us or approve of our choices.

"The courage to be happy also includes the courage to be disliked."

I think there is something quite important in that idea. When we spend too much of our lives trying to maintain a particular image or gain the approval of others, we can lose sight of the freedom that comes with simply being ourselves.

Perhaps authenticity requires us to accept that some people will misunderstand us, some won't agree with us, and some may not like us at all. And that's okay.

We can take responsibility for our actions without taking responsibility for everyone's opinion of us.


Becoming Rather Than Appearing


Perhaps the greatest challenge is learning to place less importance on how our lives look and more importance on how we actually live them.


To choose integrity when it would be easier to take a shortcut. To acknowledge a mistake rather than protect our pride. To treat people with kindness even when there is no recognition attached to it.


It is not about becoming someone who never makes mistakes or never cares what others think. We are human, and we will always have areas where we need to grow.


But there is a difference between striving to become a better person and striving to convince everyone that we already are one.


Maybe authenticity begins when we stop trying so hard to manage the perception of who we are and start paying closer attention to the reality of who we are becoming.


Because eventually, appearances fade, circumstances change, and the recognition we once sought may no longer matter.


What remains is our character, the relationships we have nurtured, the choices we have made, and the lives we have touched along the way.


Perhaps the goal was never to look like we have it all together. Perhaps it was to become someone whose life reflects what we genuinely believe in. And if that means your circle of friends needs to have a few quality friends rather than quantity of friends. So be it. 


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page